
You know how sometimes you set out to cook something improvisational and then realize you’re all unfocused? Maybe you have three different herbs on your counter, various alliums, and some stuff you pulled from your cheese drawer. You’ve bought good pasta at the Italian shop, too. But it’s not all forming a pretty picture in your mind’s eye. I find myself at that place sometimes, and it frustrates me. I guess I was subconsciously looking for a way to fix this occasional problem when this New Year I found myself clarifying my culinary head with color. I started making swatches in watercolor and placing them alongside a list of ingredients that seemed right for a dish I had in mind. The colors helped me make purer choices and get rid of excess without leaving my cooking austere. I think with luck they may reveal the soul of a dish.
I started this color matching game when I had made a pasta with chanterelles but wasn’t happy with it. It felt clunky, which was surprising, since chanterelles are so elegant. I had a few chanterelles left over, so I thought I’d try the dish again the next day. I laid out the uncooked leftover mushrooms on my counter. Their peachy beige color was so lovely, I got curious to see if I could match it. I took out my paints, and after some adjusting was happy with the color swatch I made, all at once yellow, brown, orange, and transparent. So I went on, choosing other flavors I was thinking about for the second version of the dish and painting them. I dissolved saffron in a half cup of warm chicken broth and watched the maroon threads blossom in a swirl of pure orange. My head lightened as I stared at the color. It seemed to direct me to construct the pasta in a more pinpointed way. It became apparent to me what ingredients needed to go from my first try. What went were prosciutto fat, leeks, and parsley. What stayed were what you see below to the right of my color patches.

This exercise reminded me of a few things I know but don’t always remember. For starters, not every dish needs a pork product. When I first made this pasta with chanterelles I included chopped prosciutto fat because I had it, and for no other reason. All it did was pull focus away from the delicate taste of the mushrooms. I have a tendency to enrich food with pork fat when it’s not needed. Lazy.
Not every dish needs a lot of herbs either. I chose thyme for this because I love thyme with mushrooms. But then I added parsley at the end, to finish the dish and to interrupt its more or less uniform beige color. Mistake. It visually muddied everything, making for a confusing photograph while adding nothing. Using parsley as a throwaway is culinary abuse. I know this, but sometimes I do it anyway, probably in a reflex from years cooking in French bistros where they scatter it over everything that leaves the kitchen. Parsley is a unique flavor and should be treated the same as you treat rosemary or any other aromatic. Italians know that. For instance it was the main flavoring in my mother’s pasta e fagiole, and is in my own bucatini with clams, too.

Not every Italian dish needs garlic. I didn’t include garlic in the original version of this dish, but I thought I’d mention it here, since I have sometimes thrown it in without much thought. Since I don’t always love the taste of papery winter garlic, I wasn’t tempted this time. I debated using shallots and leeks. I had both and added both to the first version of the pasta, but they only created an unrefined undertaste. Take one out, I said. I stuck with the shallots, which not only tasted sweet and deep but also had a lovely violet hue, which I think I captured with my paint.
I’m going to make more color swatch recipes, and I’ll keep you posted on my progress. The ingredient list for my tagliatelle with chanterelles and saffron is in order of use on the swatch card, so if you’re interested in trying it you can do a version with your own personal stamp, improvising the measurements.
Happy New Year, and may all your cooking be bright and clear.



























